“I used to be working on the AIS, and the physiology division was led by Professor Chris Gore. USADA commissioned him to overview Lance Armstrong’s ABP knowledge. He was my PhD supervisor and acquired me within the passport.”
The phrases of Professor Laura Lewis, director of science on the United States Anti-Doping Agency, previously on the Australian Institute of Sport, and one of many world’s main specialists on the Athlete Biological Passport (ABP).
Reid Aiken, deputy director of the ABP at WADA, the World Anti-Doping Agency, had flagged up Lewis’ haematological experience (see half one), particularly her encyclopaedic data of the potential blind spot that’s dosing micro portions of the blood-booster erythropoietin (EPO) and altitude. So, one electronic mail dropped, a swift reply, and we have been away, beginning with a reminder of what the ABP measures…
The anti-doping alarm bells are ringing
“The passport has a blue line within the center,” says Lewis. “This is the athlete’s knowledge factors [new red blood cells, aka reticulocytes, and haemoglobin levels] that go up and down. Then there’s this adaptive mannequin that WADA owns that calculates an higher and decrease restrict, that are represented by pink strains. These strains begin off fairly far aside however the extra samples you’re taking, the narrower they change into and predict inside 99% confidence the place the athletes’ worth ought to lie.”
If it is flagged by the mannequin, that is not like an EPO check, says Lewis, which might be a constructive; as an alternative, it is an alert. Another skilled examines the information and, if the alarm bells proceed to ring, two additional specialists do related.
“If all of you’re saying doping’s doubtless, then you definately write what’s referred to as a ‘joint opinion’,” says Lewis.
“That’s utilizing all the data that you have at that time, explaining the abnormality, which is shipped to the athlete. The athlete then has the chance to offer additional info that may have impacted the outcomes, like a go to to a hospital. The specialists consider that new info. If they settle for it, nothing occurs. If they do not, then you definately transfer onto arbitration and the athlete having to defend themselves and doubtlessly a sanction.”
Which is the Badlands at the moment inhabited by French rider Franck Bonnamour, who in March was launched by his staff, Decathlon-AG2R La Mondiale, after being quickly suspended by the UCI in February for anomalies in his organic passport.
The alleged transgressions really occurred when racing for B&B Hotels – KTM in 2022. The case continues, that means we’re not conscious of the precise particulars of the alleged organic passport violations – particularly, we’re unaware if the affect of altitude on haematological values offered a part of his defence.
We are conscious, nevertheless, that this can be a widespread defence. Take Kenya’s former 1500m Olympic champion Asbel Kiprop, who served a four-year ban from 2018 to 2022 after testing constructive for EPO. At his defence, the Athletics Integrity Unit (AIU) referred to as Kiprop’s clarification an “a la carte menu of the explanation why the costs must be dismissed”.
Among these, the AIU mentioned, have been that the “EPO was naturally produced attributable to intense train at altitude”, that it was produced by remedy, that the check, or the evaluation, was badly performed or that the pattern was spiked.
The three-person panel concluded that prime altitude couldn’t clarify the presence of EPO within the check and that Kiprop had produced no proof to assist different attainable explanations.
In Kiprop’s case, his organic passport was used to focus on when the anti-doping authorities ought to undertake EPO testing. This synergistic method is a helpful technique, particularly due to the problem in separating blood values at altitude and blood values when doping reasonable quantities of EPO. As we highlighted partially one, a 2022 paper by Jonas Saugy, entitled ‘Altitude and Erythropoietin: Comparative Evaluation of Their Impact on Key Parameters of the Athlete Biological Passport: A Review‘, revealed that an athlete’s blood profile when micro-dosing was “hardly distinguishable from these recognized after hypoxic publicity”.
It’s a situation Lewis is greater than conscious of.
“There have definitely been stories of athletes utilizing EPO at altitude to masks its results. When you are at altitude, your physique’s pure response to the low ranges of oxygen is to supply its personal EPO, which accelerates the manufacturing of pink blood cells. Depending on the person’s response to altitude, it could have related results on the markers as blood doping – EPO and blood transfusions – however to not the identical magnitude.
“So, it could trigger the passport to flag above these higher or decrease limits. It’s led to some athletes utilizing recombinant EPO at altitude as they really feel they will clarify the anomaly on their passport.”
Inconsistency of altitude
Lewis concedes that micro-dosing EPO at altitude does make it extra of an anti-doping problem, not solely attributable to unpicking one from the opposite however due to how a bike owner naturally reacts to altitude.
“Some say the way you react is all the way down to being a responder or non-responder to altitude,” Lewis says. “I’ve by no means subscribed to that camp because it’s too simplistic. I’ve been on coaching camps with elite athletes the place they reply one time and do not the following.
“I believe it is actually associated to plenty of elements, just like the dose of altitude that they are given. So, period, peak of the publicity, but in addition have been they in poor health after they headed to altitude? Did they’ve additional stress happening? You actually need your physique to be in an adaptive state to answer altitude. It’s why athletes who smash themselves at camp to cut back their weight have a tendency to not reply haematologically, whereas in the event that they periodise their coaching and so they’re a seasoned professional, and consuming the correct issues and so they have sufficient iron accessible, they have a tendency to have good responses.”
Lewis says that there have been makes an attempt so as to add a extra formalised altitude issue to the ABP. “But it was determined that there have been simply too many variables, so it was determined to reinforce the literature round particular person responsiveness to altitude and its impact on the markers of the organic passport as an alternative. You then depart it within the palms of the specialists who overview the passport to actually dig deep.”
That’s why athletes are inspired to offer as a lot element as attainable about, say, an altitude camp after they’re filling of their ADAMS account. This is WADA’s Anti-Doping Administration and Management System, the place, amongst many issues, athletes are required to offer a 60-minute time slot on daily basis between 5am and 11pm that anchors an athlete to a particular location for testing.
This element tangentially led us to debate a metric entitled ‘the kilometre hour’, which is what number of hours it takes to reply haematologically. (Bear with us, we do circle round to clarify this) You can learn extra about it here. The paper, entitled ‘Time for a brand new metric for hypoxic dose?’ and co-written by Lewis, launched a brand new method of taking a look at altitude publicity that mixed completely different altitudes and durations in a single unit: kilometre/hours. If you lived and skilled at round 2,200m for 22 days (528 hours), that may quantity to round 1,161km/hrs.
“Broadly, it takes round 900km/hrs for a sea-level resident to actually profit from altitude,” says Lewis, with the mannequin exhibiting a rise of haemoglobin mass of round 2% at 500/km/hr, 4% at 1,000km/hr and 6% at 2,000km/hr. The latter would realise a saving of 10bpm for any given energy output or a lift in energy of round 20 watts for a similar coronary heart price, which begs the query, why not attain out to [Edmund] Hillary-esque heights seeking much more rarefied air and doubtlessly larger efficiency?
“There’s an altitude candy spot as a result of the upper you’re, the tougher it’s to carry out high-intensity work like VO2 max work,” says Lewis. “It’s why cyclists may prepare at round 2,000m in Andorra however will sleep in an altitude tent set to three,000m.
“The drawback is, when an anti-doping management officer comes knocking, despite the fact that there’s a query about utilizing simulated hypoxia units, they could be extra centered on the truth that they’re residing at altitude and reply the query incorrectly. That would make a distinction as a result of the specialists are taking a look at skews in knowledge that they are being advised was at 2,000m however, for 10 hours an evening, that response is all the way down to publicity at 3,000m.”
So, element issues to make sure the harmless stay harmless, particularly in the case of altitude. Unless, in fact, you’re dishonest. And in the case of dishonest up excessive, creativeness counts.
“The Aderlass case uncovered athletes who headed to altitude and extracted blood whereas they have been there to speed up the regeneration of recent pink blood cells [reticulocytes]; you’d return to a ‘regular’ state quicker than when you have been taking out blood at sea stage,” says Lewis.
“Or they’d go to altitude, generate a complete lot extra pink blood cells after which extract blood on the finish of the camp that they could reinfuse again at sea stage. They have been inventive!”
DNA testing and AI are the longer term (and present)
Lewis is certainly one of many anti-doping specialists focusing their efforts on altitude. Another identify that retains cropping up is Nikolai Baastrup Nordsborg, the pinnacle of diet, train and sports activities on the University of Copenhagen. Nordsborg has led myriad research into doping and altitude, together with the genetic affect.
In the primary paper, the Norwegian had 39 topics randomly assigned to an EPO group, the place they’d obtain micro-dosing injections of 20 IU per kilogramme of physique weight, or to the placebo group, the place they acquired a saline injection. (The EPO ranges seen within the ‘naughty 90s’ and into the 2000s, and earlier than biking adopted the ABP in 2008, have been over seven instances that quantity.) They skilled at each sea stage and altitude, and every particular person acquired 11 injections, given intravenously each second day for 3 weeks.
As an apart, samples have been taken by way of dried blood spot (DBS) testing that WADA permitted in 2021. DBS is a type of blood sampling the place samples are blotted and dried on filter paper, and maintain many benefits over conventional blood sampling, together with they’re much less invasive as you solely require a drop or two and so they’re cheaper.
What have been Nordsborg and his staff in search of?
Genetic markers recognized from earlier analysis he’d undertaken that have been “delicate to blood manipulation”. For the lab coats amongst you, they have been 5′-aminolevulinate synthase (ALAS2), an enzyme concerned in haemoglobin biosynthesis and particular to erythropoiesis, and carbonic anhydrase 1 (CA1), an enzyme concerned in several cell processes, together with cell respiration, and not directly concerned in erythropoiesis. And as Nordsborg suspected, his outcomes confirmed that each genetic markers have been considerably greater when microdosing EPO to altitude alone.
Nordsborg additionally examined the affect of altitude and injecting EPO on iron metabolism. The two primary regulators of iron availability, hepcidin and erythroferrone (ERFE), are “delicate to altered erythropoietic exercise”. Vis-à-vis, Nordsborg hypothesised, after which confirmed, that they’re each “delicate markers in an anti-doping context”.
Looking in a special place
So, regardless of the problem in separating authorized and micro-dosing strategies of adjusting your blood profile, it isn’t inconceivable. But is it the panacea of modern-day anti-doping? Maybe not. “One of essentially the most enlightening research I undertook on the AIS was on the 2013 Tour of Qinghai Lake in China, the place we have been working with the Australian nationwide staff and Drapac,” says Lewis. “It’s the very best race on the earth and options one climb that peaks at over 4,100m.
“The primary purpose we selected that race was down to 2 excessive and conflicting stimuli,” Lewis provides. “The first is clearly the altitude that ought to see a major improve in haemoglobin. The second is all the way down to the variety of levels [which back then numbered 13 but now numbers eight]. Multi-stage racing has been proven to dilute haemoglobin. You’re not destroying it, however the fluid element of blood, often known as plasma, expands. It’s your kidneys’ pure response to the stress you are making use of day after day.
“The query that was related to the passport was, at altitude, which one will ‘win’ – the rise in haemoglobin or the rise in plasma quantity? I assumed that the altitude would win as a result of oxygen is fairly essential! But I used to be unsuitable – each rider’s haemoglobin stage dropped due to the quantity plasma quantity had expanded. We additionally examined a Chinese staff who have been natives at that altitude and the outcomes have been the identical – haemoglobin ranges drop, plasma quantity rises.
“That was actually essential info as a result of it confirmed us that plasma quantity, notably in biking over many lengthy days, might really be extra of a confounder to the passport than altitude itself. I believe we’ve a very good deal with on altitude, albeit as a result of micro-dosing does elevate the possibilities of false positives, it is essential for anti-doping organisations to proceed with EPO assessments hand in hand with the ABP. But then the way in which that plasma quantity can change with tapering or elevated coaching hundreds, that is a bit of bit tougher to quantify.”
To that finish, WADA has directed cash into additional analysis into plasma quantity. “I’m a part of a working group that is taking a look at quantifying plasma quantity in the actual world, in repeatable style, and never simply within the lab,” says Lewis. “That’s a problem. But not inconceivable. A examine got here out of Qatar from Louisa Lobigs that would predict plasma quantity primarily based on easy chemistry markers from a blood check.
“We examined it out on the Tour Down Under in 2020, simply earlier than COVID-19, and it predicted the adjustments in plasma quantity rather well. It’d contain one other blood check and tube to be taken from an athlete similtaneously the ABP, nevertheless it might offer you extra confidence in, is there a plasma quantity shift associated to this?” In different phrases, it’d take into consideration the affect of altitude on haemoglobin ranges and the plasma-volume affect of racing exhausting many days over.
Raphael Faiss, analysis supervisor on the Centre of Research and Expertise in Anti-Doping Sciences (REDs) on the University of Lausanne, who we met partially one, is at the moment utilising machine studying to estimate what a rider’s plasma quantity must be at any given time; synthetic intelligence is used to outline regular patterns and patterns that correspond with doping.
In truth, WADA has a number of ongoing AI initiatives that target completely different sides of the ABP, together with the flexibility to flag up ‘urine change’; in different phrases, to crack down on athletes trying to cross off someone else as them throughout a drug check. From 2012 to 2019, WADA regarded into greater than 60,000 circumstances and found a doppelganger sample in 130 of them.
The most up-to-date high-profile case involved Kenyan middle-distance runner Michael Saruni, who in February acquired a four-year ban from all competitors by sending a look-alike to offer blood and urine samples. He was alleged to have walked into a rest room after the nationwide trials for the 2022 World Championships accompanied by one other man earlier than switching garments and sending him to be examined. His elaborate ruse did not idiot an anti-doping official, nevertheless, who “observed that the individual didn’t seem like an athlete who had simply completed a race”. Saruni was later found in a rest room cubicle by investigators, however relatively than handing himself in, he tried to flee by leaping over a barred wall.
Reid Aiken, deputy director of the ABP at WADA and one other skilled we met partially one, advised us that WADA is working with the German Institute for Artificial Intelligence to determine pattern swapping by way of an AI-led pattern-recognition software. If suspicion is aroused by way of AI, the urine samples that have been taken for the steroidal module of the ABP can then be DNA examined.
All of those are improvements that can hopefully bolster the effectiveness of the ABP in its efforts to stay related, particularly when headlines are directed to initiatives just like the Enhanced Games, which might cast off drug testing altogether. It’s this evolution that is so essential, says Lewis, for the identification of cheats and the safety of the harmless.
“The ABP’s been in use for over 15 years. In that point, doping’s modified and now the [suspicious] passports look very completely different. They’re not textbook ECG profiles. Athletes are a lot smarter and extra subtle. I do not suppose we should always ever eliminate the ABP as a result of it is such a very good deterrent, however issues must evolve in order that it does not change into redundant. The concern is that anti-doping organisations spend some huge cash on ABP assessments – it is costly to gather, transport and analyse the blood – and when you’re not getting any circumstances or not seeing any profit from an organisation perspective, you begin to query, why are we pouring all that cash into this?
“I hope in one other 15 years the ABP continues to be round. But we have to higher educate the athletes on what info we have to guarantee they’re on a stage enjoying discipline with the specialists on the ABP aspect. If the athlete had low iron, for example, however did not really feel it related to flag up. Better schooling will assist them. If it is in the identical format as now, we might have failed the athletes. We should transfer with the instances to make sure the ABP’s as helpful as attainable.”
Thank you in your Cyclingnews subscription. We use our subscription charges to have the ability to preserve producing all our common nice content material in addition to extra premium items like this one. Find out extra right here.