Wind tunnel examined: 11 superbikes go face to face

To many cyclists, lusting after high-end street bikes is as a lot part of the attract of our sport as really driving. 

These machines may be costly – typically prohibitively so – however they continue to be undeniably thrilling, resulting in the whiling away of many a lunch break looking your favorite biking journal or web site. 

Even if our price range does not permit us to buy with professional intent, trickle-down know-how implies that the cutting-edge improvements we covet right this moment could turn out to be accessible to us sooner or later. So captivated we’re that we proceed to browse, even when buying a brand new bike is not on the horizon in any respect.

For a very long time, the foremost promoting level of a street bike was its weight. Aerodynamics had grown in significance, nevertheless it wasn’t till the early 2010s that producers actually began investing in ‘aero’ when designing bikes. Soon after, the aero street bike class was born.

For a time, this meant manufacturers typically had two race bikes of their steady; one for climbing mountains and one other for sprinters or flatter terrain. Some even had a 3rd ‘endurance’ bike, which had been favoured by amateurs and infrequently raced on the cobbled roads of the Spring Classics. 

Many nonetheless function that three-bike steady, however issues have moved on a bit. Aero bikes have turn out to be lighter, light-weight bikes have turn out to be extra aero, and a few manufacturers have even converged the 2 right into a single ‘one bike to rule all of them’. 

While you’d assume that makes issues easy when shopping for, the reality is that purchasing a street bike can nonetheless be sophisticated. 

Nowadays, it is uncommon to discover a new bike launch with out aerodynamic claims that look one thing like “10 watts sooner at 40km/h,” or “27 seconds sooner over 40km.” In isolation, these claims may be helpful, however they hardly ever assist us get a way of the larger image. 

Often, manufacturers will evaluate their newest launch with their very own outgoing mannequin; or one other bike of their vary. Almost by no means will you see a model evaluate its bike to the competitors, however that is we suspect right down to authorized causes or variations in testing protocols; you’ll be able to guess your backside greenback they’re all doing competitor evaluation. 

That’s the place we are available.  

We took 11 of right this moment’s greatest street bikes (in addition to an outdated rim-brake bike from 2015 as a baseline) to the wind tunnel for a back-to-back take a look at to search out out which was quickest, which was slowest, and the way a lot sooner they’re than that baseline. We additionally ran some further checks on place and wheel upgrades, which we’ll share within the coming weeks. 

Before we get into the thick of it, a fast interlude to say that this characteristic is just not sponsored. We paid the traditional business price for our wind tunnel entry and purchased or borrowed every thing used within the take a look at. This content material was made attainable solely and fully by our paying subscribers.

The Bikes

Our purpose was to have a collection of high-end street bikes that supplied a stability between what customers is likely to be trying to purchase, and a mirrored image of the bikes seen in right this moment’s WorldTour peloton. We needed a similar-level of motorbike from every model, as a result of though the aerodynamic distinction between two groupsets will likely be negligible, we discover that in some instances Dura-Ace / SRAM Red degree bikes are specced with one-piece cockpits whereas cheaper fashions have two-piece bar and stem setups. The identical goes for high-end wheels with bladed spokes. 

Some of the bikes within the take a look at are ‘all out aero’, such because the Cervélo S5 and the Scott Foil, whereas others fall extra within the ‘aero all-rounder’ class, such because the Specialized Tarmac and the brand new Trek Madone. 

Where manufacturers supplied each an aero mannequin and an aero all-rounder, corresponding to Cannondale with the SystemSix and SuperSix Evo respectively, we selected the bike that was extra generally raced within the WorldTour.  

In alphabetical order, the bikes are as follows: 

• Cannondale SuperSix Evo 4 Hi-Mod Team Edition
• Canyon Aeroad CFR
• Cervélo S5 
• Factor OSTRO VAM
• Giant Propel Advanced SL 0
• Look 795 Blade RS
• Pinarello Dogma F
• Scott Foil RC Pro
• Specialized S-Works Tarmac SL8
• Trek Madone SLR 7 Gen 8
• Van Rysel RCR Pro Team Replica 
• And our baseline: My personal 2015 Trek Emonda ALR with box-section rims, rim brakes, exterior cables and spherical bars. 

Each bike was a dimension 56cm or the model’s closest equal.

We had been restricted, to a degree, by what we may get our fingers on. For instance, we needed to incorporate the Colnago V4Rs (for a Pogačar vs Vingegaard bike comparability), a Merida Scultura, the BMC Teammachine R, the Bianchi Oltre, the Enve Melee, the brand new Van Rysel aero bike, and others, however both the bikes had been unavailable or our makes an attempt to contact the manufacturers went unanswered. 

The take a look at

We took the bikes to the wind tunnel on the Silverstone Sports Engineering Hub, testing every one’s aerodynamic efficiency, measured in Coefficient of Drag x Area (CdA). 

This is quantified in metres squared, or M^2. The drag coefficient is successfully a definition of how simply air passes over an merchandise’s floor, and is largeley affected by the form of the merchandise nevertheless it may also be affected by floor materials, and that is why many cyclists put on aero socks as a substitute of naked legs. The space is kind of merely the merchandise’s frontal space, or dimension. 

We did this through two checks – the bike alone, after which with a rider (me!) – and we needed to know three issues: 

1. Which is the quickest superbike? Of the bikes we had been capable of get our fingers on, which might take the crown? 
2. Or are all fashionable bikes inside such a decent margin that, consequently, you’ll be able to successfully ignore aerodynamic claims when shopping for your subsequent bike, and as a substitute concentrate on different elements corresponding to weight, consolation, spec and buyer expertise?
3. How a lot sooner are they than our baseline? Using my very own entry-level 2015 Trek Emonda ALR to symbolize the age-old bike you have been driving for years or the entry-level mannequin that ignited your ardour extra just lately, we needed to know the way a lot you stand to achieve by upgrading to a modern-day race bike.

Present on the day had been: 

1. Me – Josh Croxton – guiding proceedings in addition to pedalling the bike within the rider-on checks. 
2. Tom Wieckowski – answerable for bike preparation and standardisation, making certain the day may run easily.
3. Sam Gupta – All the superb pictures you see right here.
4. Andrew Daley – the superb video seize which is able to cowl our social media.
5. Max, Nick, Jack and Graham from Silverstone Sports Engineering Hub (SSE Hub) – answerable for working the tunnel itself, mounting every bike to the wind tunnel stanchions, and guiding the protocol, as defined beneath. 

Our protocol

The protocol was designed on my own with steerage from the aero consultants from SSE Hub. 

We examined at seven yaw angles: -15, -10, -5, 0, +5, +10 and +15 levels. 

All checks had been carried out at 40km/h (24.85mph), consultant of a typical beginner street race, a quick membership trip, or a sluggish skilled peloton (the 2024 Tour de France was raced at a mean of 41.4kmh).

We started the day capturing at 30km/h too, to replicate a extra all-day tempo for well-trained amateurs, however quickly realised we might run out of time to get by all of our bikes earlier than the day was up. I additionally discovered that through the second sweep of rider-on testing, fatigue of holding the stable place would set in earlier than the tip of the take a look at and the information would turn out to be much less dependable. We determined to bin that 30km/h knowledge and forge on at 40km/h solely. 

For the rider-on take a look at, we examined for 30 seconds per yaw. We may have examined longer on every take a look at, however discovered this was a pleasant sweetspot between a protracted sufficient seize to get reliable knowledge, however brief sufficient that fatigue did not set and nullify the repeatability and allowed us to get by all of the bikes within the allotted time. Cadence was held at a constant price of round 90 RPM. 

For the bike-only take a look at, we ensured the wheels had been spinning on the appropriate velocity; the behaviour of airflow over the rim and spokes may be very totally different on a static wheel, and thus not consultant of the true world. We examined for 15 seconds per yaw right here. The knowledge right here is far ‘cleaner’ (there is not any rider pedalling or having to carry a place) so higher accuracy may be obtained with out the necessity for longer captures. 

Standardisations

The wind tunnel itself is designed to account for any modifications in temperature or air density in its outcomes. Prior to every take a look at, the wind tunnel underwent a taring course of, comparable in precept to the tare in your kitchen scales or zero-offsetting your energy meter to make sure correct readings.

As at all times, we standardised as many variables as attainable. This included the bike dimension, rider place, the entrance tyre, laptop mounts, and the place related, the bottles and cages on every bike.

The wind tunnel additionally initiatives an ‘edge’ or a top level view of my place from the baseline take a look at from three angles (front-on, side-on and top-down) onto the ground, in order that I may stay in a constant place for subsequent runs. 

Each take a look at bike was a dimension 56cm, or the closest equal per the model’s geometry chart. Upon receipt, every bike was fitted to me, and positions matched to one another as intently as attainable. More on this beneath. 

We needed to check every bike as intently to how a shopping for buyer would use them in the true world, however with some concessions the place crucial to make sure constant testing. 

We eliminated laptop mounts from all bikes. We know that 95% of riders will run an out-front mount, however solely round half of the bikes featured really got here with one. We did not need some examined with and others with out, so within the absence of an out there mount for the remaining bikes, we ran all of them with out. 

The Madone, Propel and Supersix had been all designed with aero bottle cages, so we ran them for the take a look at. The remaining bikes had been all given Elite Vico Carbon cages and Elite Fly bottles – each a standard sight within the WorldTour. Our considering right here is that when you purchase these bikes and have these aero cages, you’ll use them. Therefore the aero efficiency of the bike with these cages is extra related to you than with out them. 

The Factor OSTRO VAM additionally affords aero cages too, however sadly we could not get our fingers on these in time for the take a look at. 

I stored the helmet on all day to make sure it was fitted persistently. I additionally marked my skinsuit place so it may very well be made the identical once more after rest room breaks.

Confidence

This was calculated by testing the baseline Trek Emonda ALR in the beginning and the tip of the day in similar setups. 

There appears to be some dialogue about the easiest way to then calculate the error margin from this. Some will take the common CdA from all the sweep (all seven yaw angles) and calculate the distinction between the 2. If we took this strategy, our error margin would have been 0.24% and 0.53% for the bike-only and rider-on checks respectively. 

However, others evaluate every yaw angle individually and take the largest of those variations. We selected to take this strategy within the curiosity of providing fairer, extra assured conclusions for our readers. 

In addition, the next elements may have an effect on the outcomes:

• The handlebars fitted ranged from 38cm to 42cm, which meant my fingers had been in a barely totally different place. Using the ‘Edge’ markings that Silverstone supplies, I used to be capable of roll my wrists inward or outward to standardise my driving place, and we had been meticulous sufficient with our pre-test bike match changes that I used to be capable of offset the variations and maintain myself within the baseline place properly. We, and extra importantly the group from SSE Hub, had been glad that my physique place was constant throughout checks.
• The bike-only checks would even be affected by differing bar widths because of the elevated floor space, however with out the potential impact on the rider’s place. The impact is small when in comparison with all the bike’s dimension and the drag coefficient of every constituent half hitting the wind (entrance on or downstream), however not insignificant.
• Holding every bike in place was a set of stanchions. No changes are made to account for them, given they’re the identical for all bikes and we’re within the variations quite than absolutely the values. However, an additional plate was added with a view to mount the Pinarello as a consequence of its blind drive-side dropouts, decreasing our confidence within the dataset for this bike. We nonetheless assume the information will likely be attention-grabbing to our readers, so have chosen to share our findings as we’ve them. Canyon and Cannondale’s bikes additionally characteristic blind dropouts, however each manufacturers despatched drilled-out bikes that may very well be mounted as regular.

Additional particulars and disclaimers

Cyclingnews doesn’t declare that this knowledge is the ultimate phrase on the aerodynamic efficiency of the bikes featured, however quite a further stream of unbiased, unbiased testing and knowledge for our readers. 

The outcomes are merely consultant of our day of testing. We hope that being clear about our technique and our protocol permits readers to understand the information whereas additionally understanding the larger image. 

The charts proven within the outcomes beneath present the information with the error margins highlighted. For simplicity, once we report the CdA for every bike/take a look at, we’ll achieve this because it got here out of the wind tunnel to 4 vital figures.

With this knowledge, we have finished some calculations to resolve for energy (watts) and velocity (km/h) at totally different energy outputs. These calculations don’t think about further losses corresponding to drivetrain friction or rolling resistance, nor do they issue within the chance of experiencing such yaw angles on the given speeds. These are made to assist our readers perceive the potential impression (massive or small) that CdA could have. 

We have additionally included the load of every bike. These are actual weights taken moments earlier than being despatched into the wind tunnel of their ready-to-test state with pedals and bottle cages fitted.

We additionally perceive that different elements come into play when shopping for a street bike, corresponding to the way it rides, weight, consolation, spec, tyre clearance, aesthetics, buyer expertise and extra. The greatest street bikes for you’ll be a stability of these options alongside aerodynamics, every weighted per your preferences. 

The outcomes

Rider on bike outcomes

Here you’ll be able to see the CdA plotted towards Yaw for every bike. The two traces that sit greater than the remaining are the 2 runs we did on our baseline bike. This reveals that every one of our new superbikes have a decrease drag coefficient than a 10-year-old alloy bike: A optimistic begin!

Removing the 2 baseline runs, you’ll be able to see that the remainder of the bikes are shut to one another, with the traces overlapping at numerous factors. At face worth, this implies that some bikes are extra aerodynamic at sure yaw angles, whereas being slower at others. 

However, once you add in our error bars, drawn from our confidence margin defined above, it turns into clear that the outcomes overlap. We cannot confidently conclude a stand-out winner right here. 

Using simply the common CdA figures, this bar chart with the error bars overlaid reveals issues extra clearly. Of the primary 10 bikes, we won’t confidently conclude an order. Besides realizing that the baseline bike is considerably slower, we will solely actually conclude that the Look Blade 795 RS is slower than the Specialized, Trek, Factor Cervélo and Canyon.

This graph reveals the ability required at 40km/h for every of the bikes. The Specialized Tarmac sits at 280.2 watts (+/- our error of three.91 watts). 

The Look Blade 795 RS is at 286.29 watts, once more with the identical 3.91-watt leeway. Factoring in that margin, the distinction between our superbikes may very well be nothing in any respect, nevertheless it may very well be as a lot as 13.91 watts.

The baseline Trek Emonda ALR got here out at 304.67 watts. Factoring in that margin once more, the S-Works Tarmac is a minimum of 16.65 watts sooner than the baseline however may very well be as a lot as 32.29 watts sooner. 

Bike solely outcomes

As with the rider-on-bike knowledge above, we will see that many of the race bikes sit in a cluster collectively, whereas the 2 baseline bike runs sit considerably greater. This reveals that the race bikes are usually extra aerodynamic than the baseline. Another good begin!

However, with the 2 baseline runs eliminated we will see that, not like the rider-on-bike knowledge, the remaining traces have a bit extra consistency. By this, we imply {that a} bike that’s sooner at a given yaw is usually sooner at different yaw angles too. There are some situations of traces crossing over, however the knowledge seems cleaner.

And right here, with the error margin added in, we will see that though there’s nonetheless some crossover, we will confidently conclude that a few of the bikes are sooner than others, and that the Look is markedly slower. We nonetheless cannot fairly tease out an outright winner, however we may be assured in saying the Cervelo S5 is quick at zero yaw, including extra drag within the crosswinds, whereas the Factor OSTRO tends to be much less fast at zero yaw, however performs properly throughout the complete sweep. 

And right here with the common CdA throughout the complete sweep for every bike, and exhibiting the error bars once more, we will conclude that the Factor OSTRO VAM is quickest, with a mean CdA of 0.0882 (+/- 0.0010). 

However, the Scott Foil and Cervélo S5 had been shut sufficient (at 0.0897 and 0.0900 respectively (+/- 0.0010)) that they fall inside our margin of error, in order that they can also lay declare to victory. 

The Canyon Aeroad and Cannondale SuperSix sit shut behind, inside 0.0004 m^2 of one another, and due to this fact can each lay declare to 2nd place. 

The Pinarello Dogma F and S-Works Tarmac sit a bit additional again, however can each lay declare to a podium end when our margin is factored in. 

The Van Rysel RCR Pro, Giant Propel and Trek Madone all sit mid desk, whereas the Look Blade 795 RS languishes behind. All bikes are considerably sooner than our baseline, with its CdA of 0.1370.

We know that bikes can not pedal themselves, however for comparability, this graph reveals the ability required at 40km/h for every of their respective CdA figures above. 

The Factor OSTRO VAM lands at 72.59 watts (+/- 0.85 watts).

Our slowest superbike, the Look Blade 795 RS, sits at 84.95 watts with that very same 0.85-watt margin. 

The baseline bike’s greatest end result was 112.74 watts, however once you think about that margin, you stand to save lots of between 38.45 and 41.85 watts. 

It’s value remembering, nonetheless, that it is a reflection of bike-only knowledge. Given the bike is simply a fraction of the whole CdA a bike owner could have, the impact will likely be decreased, therefore the smaller distinction outlined within the rider-on-bike knowledge above. 

The conclusions

Which bike is the quickest?

Although the Specialized Tarmac got here out on high in our rider-on-bike take a look at, intently adopted by the Trek Madone and the Factor OSTRO VAM, our margin of confidence implies that on one other day, any of the bikes may have landed on high. 

It is due to this fact troublesome to attract any significant or assured conclusion as to the quickest bike. 

What’s extra, at every totally different yaw angle, the order flip-flops rather a lot, additional suggesting our variability is bigger than the distinction between every bike. While our margin is reflective of typical rider-on-bike knowledge, when mixed with the opposite issues and the tightly packed outcomes, we’re unable to confidently say that anybody bike is the out-and-out quickest. Therefore, if contemplating which one to purchase, we might have a look at different elements corresponding to weight and trip high quality. 

From the bike-only knowledge, the outcomes seem cleaner, with extra constant outcomes throughout the seven yaw angles. The high of the desk is full of the extra devoted aero bikes such because the Factor, Scott and Cervelo, however the extra ‘all-rounder’ bikes maintain their very own properly at round 2-5 watts behind. 

Taking under consideration an unweighted common CdA on the seven yaw angles, the Factor Ostro was the quickest on this take a look at, however when factoring in our margin of error, it may end as little as third. That’s nonetheless a really spectacular end result given it was additionally the second-lightest on the day at 7.23kg. 

However, you can argue that the Cervélo S5 would really be the quickest in the true world as a consequence of its low-yaw efficiency. At 40km/h you usually tend to expertise decrease yaw angles because of the onrushing wind.

The Cannondale SuperSix Evo additionally carried out properly for an ‘all-rounder’, and though it landed in fifth on the day, given our CdA error margin of 0.0010, it may end as excessive as 2nd.

The solely bike to sit down outdoors of the ballpark is the Look Blade 795 RS, which languishes at round 12 watts behind. 

Our baseline Trek Emonda sits at an extra ~28 watts again, or round 40 watts behind the OSTRO VAM. 

To reply our earlier query of whether or not fashionable bikes are all inside such a small margin which you can ignore the aero claims made by producers, the reply is… form of! We may need been unable to confidently conclude which bike is the quickest, however we had been capable of finding the slowest, and all of our superbikes had been a marked step above the baseline. 

With that in thoughts, you can’t ignore aerodynamics totally when shopping for your subsequent bike. Given the rider-on distinction between the perfect and worst race bikes right here may very well be as massive as 13.90 watts, you continue to stand to lose velocity when you purchase the incorrect bike.

How many watts are you able to save vs your outdated bike?

If we’re blissful to simply accept that our baseline Trek Emonda from 2015 is consultant of your generic outdated bike, then the financial savings may be anyplace between 16.65 and 32.29 watts when in comparison with the quickest on take a look at. 

Even at a extra attainable solo trip tempo of 30km/h, you stand to save lots of between 7.03 and 13.62 watts. 

However, when you extrapolate the information to 50km/h, the saving grows to between 32.54 and 63.05 watts, nevertheless it’s value saying you are unlikely to have the ability to maintain this tempo fore various minutes with out drafting in a gaggle, the place the aerodynamic requirement turns into lessened. 

It’s additionally value noting that there are cheaper methods to save lots of this many watts. You may purchase an aero helmet, a skinsuit, some new wheels and enhance your place for considerably lower than even the most affordable bike on this take a look at, however when you’re on the lookout for a cause to spend the cash, you now have one. You’re welcome. 

Results and knowledge for every particular person bike

We have ordered this part by the common (unweighted) CdA from the seven yaw angles from the extra dependable bike-only take a look at knowledge. Starting with our baseline, we’ll work down from the least aerodynamic to essentially the most, because the outcomes got here out of the wind tunnel.

For every bike, we’ll checklist the unweighted common CdA from the seven yaw angles in every take a look at individually, together with an accompanying line graph. 

We will then use it to calculate the ability required to trip at 40km/h (24.85mph) utilizing the next calculation, the place velocity = metres per second.

Power (watts) = 0.5 x AirDensity x CdA x Velocity^3

We can even calculate the time taken to trip 40km at a gradual 250 watts, utilizing the next calculation: 

Speed (km/h) = 3.6 x ((Power / (0.5 x AirDensity x CdA)) ^⅓)

For each, we’ll use a constant air density of 1.2kg/m3.

We will report each as a delta (the distinction) towards our baseline bike.

Baseline: Trek Emonda ALR 2015

The baseline bike for our take a look at is my very personal bike. I purchased it in round 2017 as a winter coaching bike. It served me properly for round three years, however ever since I began at Cyclingnews, it has been in retirement as different take a look at bikes took priority. 

The cause for utilizing this bike is twofold. First, it is ours – we will maintain it on this actual state and convey it again to the wind tunnel in future checks and hopefully have the ability to evaluate future take a look at knowledge to the information featured right here. 

What’s extra, we expect it loosely represents Your Generic Basic Bike. So you may get a really feel for what number of watts you are prone to save by upgrading from a primary bike to an aero-optimised race bike. 

Look Blade 795 RS

The Look Blade 795 RS was within the headlines on the finish of this 12 months’s Tour de France after Guillaume Martin complained about its weight. At 7.75kg, it is not the lightest right here – the S-Works Tarmac is over 500g lighter – nevertheless it actually is not the heaviest. 

However, it’s the slowest of our superbikes, coming in final place in each checks. That is not conclusive within the rider-on take a look at with our margin of error taken under consideration, however within the bike-only take a look at, it was slower than each different bike at every of the seven yaw angles examined. 

With that mentioned, it was nonetheless considerably sooner than our baseline bike. With a rider on, you’d nonetheless stand to save lots of between 10.57 and 26.19 watts by upgrading. 

Giant Propel Advanced SL 0

By definition, the Propel is Giant’s devoted aero race bike, sitting alongside the pure featherweight TCR. 

Hampered considerably by the UCI’s 6.8kg rule, the TCR was launched this 12 months with a main concentrate on higher building and improved aerodynamics, whereas the Propel launched final 12 months aiming to be extra of a one-bike resolution, shedding weight within the course of. They appear destined to merge within the coming years. 

With that mentioned, Giant designs its bikes with a pedalling model, (rightly) arguing that bikes do not pedal themselves, so it is best to bear that in thoughts when studying the bike-only outcomes proven right here. 

Trek Madone SLR 7 Gen 8

The newest Madone is the results of Trek’s determination to merge its light-weight Emonda and aero Madone fashions into one bike, and though it makes use of slimmed down tubes, Trek says it really outperforms the outgoing aero-first Madone within the wind tunnel. 

Trek admits that that is thanks largely to the aero bottle cages, however we won’t dispute the argument that in case you have them, you will use them. That’s why we ran them for this take a look at. 

Like the Propel above, the Madone is one other that fared higher with a rider on than with out. 

Van Rysel RCR Pro

First up, I need to apologise for claiming {that a} £9000 bike is anyplace close to a budget-friendly. I recognize that is nonetheless an inordinate sum of money for a bicycle, however as a model, Van Rysel is constructing its popularity on value. 

The model was sprung into the highlight when its mother or father firm, Decathlon, turned the title sponsor of French WorldTour group, Decathlon AG2R La Mondiale. 

And in comparison with the rivals right here, it’s the worth choice. With a top-tier Dura-Ace groupset, the Van Rysel is £299 cheaper than the next-cheapest equivalent-spec bike, the Aeroad CFR from direct-to-consumer model Canyon. 

The Trek Madone does really are available cheaper, however the bike we managed to supply was the Force AXS outfitted, quite than the top-tier Red AXS. 

Despite that value distinction, it is properly throughout the aero and weight ballpark. It is within the backside half of a tightly-packed aero desk, and weighs simply 7.54kg. 

Specialized S-Works Tarmac SL8

The Specialized S-Works Tarmac SL8, full with new SRAM Red AXS groupset right here, made headlines at its launch in 2023 when the protruding head tube was dubbed the ‘velocity sniffer’. 

The Tarmac is arguably the bike with the largest fan base on this checklist, maybe even the world. Evidence of that got here per week previous to its launch, when, such was the urge for food to know in regards to the impending new bike, that nearly of all of Specialized’s advertising materials was hacked and leaked. 

It is the lightest bike on this checklist at 7.18kg with pedals and bottle cages, nevertheless it was outperformed within the aerodynamics stakes. It landed in at seventh in our bike-only take a look at, however with the error margin taken under consideration, it might probably lay declare to as excessive as third place. 

Pinarello Dogma F

The Dogma F launched simply forward of the 2024 Tour de France, claiming to be 108g lighter – just below half of which got here by a brand new cockpit – in addition to an extended wheelbase, 30c tyre clearance, and a 0.2% enchancment within the drag coefficient. For context, that is round 0.00027kg/m^2 distinction in CdA, or round 0.28 watts at 40km/h. 

In our checks, we had been compelled to mount the Dogma F utilizing a further plate because of the closed or ‘blind’ dropouts. This may have added a small quantity of drag, however we won’t make sure precisely how a lot. 

The Dogma was additionally one of many lighter bikes in our take a look at, tipping our scales at 7.20kg on the nostril.

Cannondale SuperSix Evo 4

I do know this web page is all about scientifically confirmed knowledge, however permit me this one opinion: The SuperSix Evo 4, on this colourway, is the best-looking bike of the bunch. 

Unfortunately you’ll be able to’t really purchase the precise bike we examined. We bought our fingers on one of many team-edition Hi-Mod bikes with the Dura-Ace groupset. 

The closest we may get as a shopper is shopping for the Lab71 mannequin with SRAM Red, at an eyewatering £12,500. 

Regardless, the SuperSix landed a reasonably first rate end result given it is not even Cannondale’s devoted aero bike (that declare goes to the SystemSix). It got here out fifth in our bike-only take a look at, however with the margin of error, it might probably lay declare to 2nd place. That margin goes the opposite means too, although, so it may be as little as seventh. 

Canyon Aeroad CFR

At the launch of this newest Aeroad, Canyon discovered it was sooner than the Tarmac SL8 on common, and sooner than the Cervélo S5 at greater yaw, with the Cervélo edging barely forward at zero yaw. Our uncooked knowledge agrees, however as a consequence of our error margin, we can not assure that it wasn’t merely a results of a change in situations all through the day. 

The Aeroad CFR affords wonderful worth when in comparison with the remainder of the bikes right here. It is likely to be just a few hundred kilos greater than the Van Rysel, however with its width-adjustable handlebars and height-adjustable cockpit (that does not want you to chop the steerer tube within the course of), it’s going to prevent from presumably needing to purchase a separate cockpit as soon as you have had a motorbike match. 

It is Canyon’s devoted aero bike, sitting alongside the extra light-weight Ultimate CFR. Despite that, it weighs about the identical because the Look Blade 795 RS, or round 740 grams lower than the Force-AXS outfitted Cervélo. Like Giant’s Propel/TCR combo, we additionally predict these two will merge in just a few years. 

Also like Giant, Canyon designs the bike with a pedalling dummy it calls Ferdie, and as such, it is best to bear that in thoughts when studying the bike-only outcomes proven right here. 

Cervélo S5

The Cervélo S5 is unashamedly a devoted aero bike, with its v-shaped cockpit, deep tubes and rear-wheel-wrapping seat tube. As a end result, it is no featherweight. 

That’s a barely unfair evaluation given the bike we’ve right here is Force-AXS outfitted, quite than Red, nevertheless it nonetheless ideas the scales at 340 grams greater than the similarly-specced Madone. 

Found beneath the Visma-Lease a Bike group, the S5 has crossed many a end line in first place, though the group’s two-time Tour de France winner, Jonas Vingegaard, typically reaches for the lighter-weight R5 on hillier days. 

In our bike-only take a look at, the S5 is one in all simply three bikes that may lay declare to 1st place, as soon as our margin of error has been factored in. However, provided that it goes each methods, it may additionally drop to seventh.

Scott Foil RC Pro

Although the rumourmill is telling us {that a} new Scott Addict ‘all-rounder bike’ ought to be launching within the not-too-distant future, we’re but to see something beneath the riders on the model’s sponsored WorldTour group, DSM-Firmenich-Post NL. Their race bike of alternative continues to be the Foil aero bike. 

At 7.87kg, it is not going to hassle the UCI minimal weight rule anytime quickly, however that is much less of a priority given its major concern goes quick on flatter terrain. If our outcomes are something to go by, it ought to do this properly, because it landed in 2nd place. 

With our error margin, it might probably lay declare to 1st place, however as that goes each methods, it may additionally fall as little as seventh. 

Factor OSTRO VAM

The quickest bike in our bike-only take a look at, the Factor OSTRO VAM can also be the second lightest, simply 50 grams heavier than the Tarmac SL8. With our error margin factored in, it’s nonetheless assured a podium end, solely the Cervelo and the Scott can usurp it; a powerful end result for a relatively small model.

Unfortunately, we had been unable to pay money for the aero bottle cages that the bike will historically ship with, so for anybody shopping for it, it is likely to be even sooner. 

I just lately interviewed the model’s founder and CEO, Rob Gitelis, who spoke of his personal profession, how Factor got here to be, and his loyalty to his workers by the powerful COVID interval. 

Given the efficiency of this bike, that loyalty is seemingly paying off. 

The takeaways

There we’ve it, 11 superbikes plus my outdated winter bike as a baseline comparability.

We’ve drawn out the conclusions above, highlighting some attention-grabbing variations within the bike-only checks, in addition to concluding that the variations are sufficiently small with a rider on that fashionable bikes are all inside a ballpark, however that ballpark nonetheless stands to save lots of you a superb few watts towards a budget-friendly bike. 

Or to place it one other means, it can save you watts by upgrading your bike, however in the case of deciding what to improve to, different elements corresponding to weight and trip high quality are extra essential than the one or two watts you may (or may not) save. 

With these conclusions in thoughts, what have we discovered?

1. Aero is not every thing

Despite aerodynamics (rightly) taking priority when evaluating bike efficiency, one factor we will be taught right here is that after you’re assured that you’re within the ballpark, you’ll be able to focus your consideration elsewhere. 

Whether which means you concentrate on weight, spec, or just the bike you want the color of most, it does not actually matter. You do you.

2. Buy a brand new helmet first

This is not the primary time we have been to the wind tunnel to check biking tech. You may recall that we went to a wind tunnel in May to check street bike helmets, and again in 2022 to aero take a look at street wheels. 

The winner of our helmet take a look at was the POC Procen Air, which saved 12.76 watts towards the slowest on take a look at at 40km/h. 

The winner of our wheel take a look at was the DT Swiss ARC 1100 Dicut, at 62mm deep. Compared to the slowest on take a look at, they’d prevent 3.87 watts at 40km/h. The caveat there’s that the ‘slowest’ had been nonetheless high-quality aero wheels from Reserve. 

As the information got here out of our wind tunnel (ignoring our margin for a second), the distinction between the Tarmac SL8 right here and our baseline Emonda is 24.47 watts (with a rider on) however when in comparison with the slowest of the brand new bikes, the Look Blade 795 RS, the distinction is far much less, at simply 6.09 watts. 

Given a brand new helmet will price you three figures, whereas a motorbike and wheels will price you 4, that is the place we might spend our cash first. 

As at all times, the positive aspects on the desk are completely depending on what you are beginning with, so widespread sense shall prevail. Or you can deal with your self and improve every thing!

3. You do not must be a professional to trip a quick bike

The watt financial savings right here have been calculated at 40km/h for causes outlined above, however we will extrapolate the CdA to totally different speeds to calculate the financial savings. 

Most eager amateurs will have the ability to maintain 30km/h for prolonged intervals of time, and the distinction on provide right here at that velocity remains to be vital. Upgrading from the Trek Emonda ALR to the quickest bike on take a look at, you stand to save lots of between 7.03 and 13.62 watts. 

Thank yous

To spherical off, I needed to finish this characteristic with just a few thank yous to those that helped make it attainable. 

Each of the manufacturers featured: For the mortgage of the bikes proven

Silverstone Sports Engineering Hub: For their steerage on protocol, working the wind tunnel for us, and for spending the night previous to the take a look at understanding learn how to mount the Pinarello Dogma F, with its blind dropouts, so we may profit from the next day’s testing. 

Special due to Canyon, who despatched its drilled-out Aeroad utilized in its personal wind tunnel testing, to assist us get across the blind dropouts. 

Special due to Cannondale, who shipped the model’s drilled-out fork in a single day from the USA to the UK, to assist us get across the blind dropout.

Madison UK: For the mortgage of Elite Vico Carbon bottle cages and Elite Fly bottles.

Continental Tyres: For the mortgage of GP5000 S TR tyres.

If you subscribe to Cyclingnews, it is best to join our new subscriber-only e-newsletter. From unique interviews and tech galleries to race evaluation and in-depth options, the Musette means you will by no means miss out on member-exclusive content material. Sign up now.